Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

Thomas Oliver

In the fall of 1945, two men beat and robbed a 70-year-old woman in Manhattan, New York. The victim identified Eddie Lee Wilbur as one of the robbers. Wilbur then named Thomas Oliver as his accomplice. On October 23, 1945, police arrested 18-year-old Oliver, who had a criminal record. The victim then identified Oliver as the second robber, and he was charged with armed robbery.

Oliver’s case went to trial in February 1946 in the Court of General Sessions of New York County, with Judge Owen W. Bohan presiding. Available records do not indicate whether Oliver’s trial was a bench trial or before a jury. Oliver was convicted of first-degree robbery on February 26, 1946, and sentenced to 10 to 15 years in prison.

After Oliver’s conviction, Wilbur told authorities that Oliver had not been his accomplice. He said a different man, whom he knew only as “Jay,” was the second robber. Though he did not know Jay’s last name, Wilbur gave police the names of bars where Jay typically spent time.

When interviewed again after Wilbur made this statement, the victim said she was not certain Oliver had been Wilbur’s accomplice. She said she believed she may have identified Oliver because she had frequently seen him and Wilbur together in their neighborhood and associated them with one another.

The police found “Jay” and brought him to the district attorney for questioning in December 1946. Jay confessed to assisting Wilbur with the crime. He pled guilty to robbery and was sentenced to five to 10 years in prison. Available records do not provide Jay's full name.

In March 1947, Oliver’s conviction was set aside and the charge against him was dismissed.

On April 12, 1947, New York Governor Thomas E. Dewey signed a bill, introduced by Senator Kenneth Sherbell and Assemblyman Samuel Kaplan, permitting Oliver to seek compensation from the state for his erroneous conviction and imprisonment. The state awarded Oliver $7,200 in December 1948.

- Meghan Barrett Cousino
County:New York
Most Serious Crime:Robbery
Reported Crime Date:1945
Sentence:10 to 15 years
Race/Ethnicity:Don't Know
Age at the date of crime:18
Contributing Factors:Mistaken Witness ID, Perjury or False Accusation