Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

Virginia LeFever

Other Ohio No Crime Cases
In September 1988, 41-year-old William LeFever was found suffering from an acute drug overdose in his home in Newark, Ohio. He was taken to Licking Memorial Hospital in Newark where he died the following day.

William was in the middle of a messy divorce with his 37-year-old wife, Virginia LeFever, and she told police that he had committed suicide by overdosing on antidepressants. She said had found an empty bottle of his antidepressants in their home shortly before he was taken to the hospital.

The coroner determined that William died from an overdose of the antidepressants, but that he would have died much sooner if he had ingested an entire bottle as Virginia claimed.

Virginia went to trial in Licking County Court of Common Pleas and her case was heard by a judge without a jury. The prosecution’s expert toxicologist, Franklin County toxicologist James Ferguson, provided critical evidence. Ferguson testified that only an injection of the medication would explain the course of William’s overdose, and he believed the evidence showed that someone had poisoned him.

The prosecution argued that Virginia, a registered nurse, gave that injection to her husband, and that when he did not die soon enough, she shut him in a closed room with a pesticide fumigant.

In February, 1990, the trial judge convicted Virginia of aggravated murder in February 1990, and she was sentenced to life in prison.

In 2010, Virginia’s attorney discovered that Ferguson, the toxicologist, had lied about his credentials at Virginia’s criminal trial and in other, unrelated court proceedings.

In November 2010, the trial court judge vacated Virginia’s conviction and she was released.

The prosecution dismissed the charges against her on April 21, 2011, although the charges were not dismissed with prejudice, meaning the charges could possibly be refiled. Prosecutor Kenneth Oswalt said in a statement that there was not enough evidence left "untainted" by Ferguson to go forward with a retrial.

LeFever later filed a federal civil rights lawsuit seeking damages and she filed a claim for state compensation. Both the lawsuit and the compensation were dismissed.

At the time of her arrest, LeFever had been studying for a nursing degree. After her conviction was vacated and dismissed, she returned to Ohio State Univeristy and obtained a bachelor's degree in nursing.

Lefever's attorney, Bart Keyes, refiled her state compensation claim based on a legislative change in the compensation statute. Prior to the change, an exoneree could not obtain compensation if the state had not dismissed the charges with prejudice. The change in the statute elminated that provision.

Keyes, an attorney with the Cooper Elliott law firm in Columbus, said, “She had nothing to do with her husband’s death. We are extremely confident in showing her innocence when she finally gets her day in court." The claim was settled for $2,325,000.
- Stephanie Denzel

Report an error or add more information about this case.

Posting Date:  Before June 2012
Last Updated: 3/29/2022
Most Serious Crime:Murder
Additional Convictions:
Reported Crime Date:1988
Age at the date of reported crime:37
Contributing Factors:False or Misleading Forensic Evidence, Perjury or False Accusation, Official Misconduct
Did DNA evidence contribute to the exoneration?:No