Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

Nancy Louise Botts

Convicted of check forgery in the Howard County Circuit Court of Indiana on November 22, 1934, Nancy Louise Botts was pardoned 13 months later, when the forgeries continued after Botts was incarcerated. Shortly thereafter, the actual culprit, Vivian Dorsett, admitted that she had committed the crimes.

Seven merchants in Kokomo, Indiana, including Montgomery Ward & Co., J.C. Penney Co., and G.R. Kinney Co., had been victimized by a woman passing bad checks. Employees who had witnessed the transactions identified Botts as the perpetrator. Botts, a pregnant housewife, claimed that she had never been to Kokomo and three of her neighbors testified that they saw her at home in her apartment in Brazil, Indiana – 114 miles from Kokomo – on the days of the alleged crimes. Her insurance agent testified that on one of the days in question, he was at her apartment collecting a premium from her.

Despite the alibis presented, Botts was convicted by a jury and given a sentence of 2 to 14 years in the Indiana State Women’s Prison. The stress of the ordeal caused the 28-year-old Botts to miscarry.

After Botts began to serve her sentence, the forgeries continued, forcing authorities to reopen the investigation. They began showing Botts’s photograph to employees at the stores where the forged checks had been passed, but they remained firm in their identification. The authorities then determined that there must be a “double” of Botts passing the forged checks.

Convinced that Botts could not be guilty, C.A. O’Neal, chief of police in Kokomo, advised the State Clemency Commission that Botts was undoubtedly innocent. On the recommendation of the Commission, Indiana Governor Paul V. McNutt pardoned Botts on December 14, 1935. Shortly after Botts’s release, 29-year-old Vivian Dorsett, mother of seven children, read an account of Botts’s plight in the newspaper and realized that she had been responsible for sending an innocent woman to prison. She contacted authorities and admitted to all crimes for which Botts had been convicted, and on July 24, 1937, Dorsett and her husband, Fred C. Dorsett, were both arrested in Indianapolis, Indiana and charged with passing hundreds of fraudulent checks in Indiana.

On March 9, 1939, Botts was awarded $4,000 by the State Legislature as compensation for her wrongful imprisonment.

- Adam Long

 

State:IN
County:Howard
Most Serious Crime:Forgery or Counterfeiting
Reported Crime Date:1934
Convicted:1934
Exonerated:1935
Sentence:2 to 14 years
Race:Caucasian
Sex:Female
Age at the date of crime:27
Contributing Factors:Mistaken Witness ID