Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
History and Traditions
Student Profile
The Honorable John Samuel McDonald
Class of: 1891

Source: Portrait from the Michigan Supreme Court Historical Society website


John S. McDonald served as a Michigan Supreme Court justice from 1922 through 1933.
John S. McDonald was born in Dundas County, Ontario, on February 8, 1865. When he was about two years old, his family moved to a farm near Thamesville, Ontario. He attended school at Ridgetown, Ontario, and in 1887 attended Victoria University in Coburg. After teaching school for a short time in Florence, Ontario, he came to Grand Rapids, Michigan, where he continued teaching for two years in Seymour School. His earnings enabled him to enter the University of Michigan Law School, but at the end of one year he returned to Grand Rapids and entered the law offices of Eggleston & McBride, where he completed his law studies and was admitted to the Bar. In June of 1924, the Board of Regents of the University of Michigan conferred on him an honorary degree of Doctor of Laws as of the class of 1891.
In the fall of 1906, he was elected Prosecuting Attorney of Kent County, serving until March 1908, when Governor Fred Warner appointed him Circuit Judge of Kent County to fill a vacancy caused by the death of Judge Alfred Wolcott. He filled this office until March of 1922, when Governor Alex J. Groesbeck appointed him a justice of the Michigan Supreme Court. He was later elected and re-elected and served until January 1, 1934, when he returned to private practice in Grand Rapids in partnership with his son John Duncan McDonald, under the firm name of McDonald & McDonald.
In 1939, he was appointed Chief Counsel for the State of Michigan in the Grand Trunk Railroad litigation. He rounded out a distinguished legal career when he tried the Grand Trunk tax cases in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan. In that litigation he won a brilliant victory for the State, securing a payment of back taxes in excess of $1,000,000 and establishing a legal method by which the State Tax Commission might properly compute the valuation of railroad properties. In addition to his judicial and legal career, McDonald served with distinction as the Chairman of the State Liquor Control Commission following the repeal of Prohibition.
John S. McDonald died on July 6, 1941. (Michigan Supreme Court. Michigan Reports: Cases Decided by the Supreme Court of Michigan. Chicago: Callaghan and Co., 1879 - 1948, Vol. 299.)
--  From the Michigan Supreme Court Historical Society website
Image Biography

Click on the thumbnail to enlarge

1922-34, on Michigan Supreme Court . New York Times, 15. John Samuel Mcdonal
Additional Information on The Honorable John Samuel McDonald
Browse a different year
Members of Class of 1891
Abbott, Fred Hull
Abbott, Howard Townsend
Abbott, Lysle Ivor
Aldrich, Willard
Allen, William Frederick
Anthony, Daniel Read
Applegate, William Allen
Arand, Charles Alvin
Ayres, John Bunyan
Babcock, Charles Ebenezer
Bacon, Nathaniel Holley
Baker, Terry Ligon
Baldwin, Linnaeus Sumner
Bannasch, Richard
Bauer, August
Beardsley, Charles Davenport
Bejcek, Charles Albert
Belford, Fordyce
Benson, George Elmer
Benz, Frederick William
Bergen, Jacob Blackford
Bevington, Verne Lile
Bird, Harlan Martin
Blakely, William Addison
Boevers, John Charles
Boyd, John Nelson
Boynton, Charles Albert
Brown, George Arthur
Brown, George Westfall
Browning, George Kime
Buenting, Lueppo Dedrick
Bunting, John Elmer
Burger, Arnold Henry
Butler, Augustus Seymour
Butler, Charles Cicero
Butterfield, Ora Elmer
Cairns, William Frederick S.
Callaway, Llewellyn Link
Campbell, William Clark
Carpenter, Wroe Leon
Cassin, Charles Michael
Caukin, Lavant Z.
Caulk, Ulysses Grant
Cavanaugh, Thomas James
Chase, Benjamin Franklin
Christie, Frank Livingston
Churchill, William Henry
Cochran, William Duffield
Cohen, Solomon
Condon, John Thomas
Cooper, Samuel Sterritt
Cort, William Eisaman
Cosgrave, Patrick James
Cramer, Seward
Crane, Riley Leonard
Cress, Edward Alexander
Cross, Albert Morris
Cummiskey, John
Curtis, Jesse W.
Danforth, Asa Hamilton
Davis, Alfred Job
Davis, Brayton Eugene
Davis, Elmer E.
Davis, Ferman Enes
Davis, James Robert
Davis, Ora DeLos
Dedrick, Walter Reuben
Deyoe, Bert Albert
Dinius, Wesley Fillmore
Donovan, Jeremiah
Dowling, Thomas Joseph
Downing, Harry Finis
Duncan, Guy Dale
Dundey, Charles Lewis
Duvall, Samuel
Dwan, John
Eberhardt, Frederick
Edson, John Murray
Ellis, Hudson Pomeroy
Evans, Elmer
Everts, Olen Lee
Ferry, Pierre Peyre
Foreman, Ulysses Grant
Forkner, Henry Allen
Francis, Robert Bruce
Frazer, Walter Charles
Free, Abram Lynn
Freeman, James Willis
Fuller, William Hayes
Gamble, Walter Joseph
Gilbert, Parmius Calvin
Goodrich, Norman Edgar
Gormley, Austin Carlos
Gough, Aurelian Bruce
Gould, Lawrence Peck
Haines, Harry Samuel
Hally, Patrick J. M.
Hamilton, Rolland Burritt
Hammerle, Franklin Thomas
Hamper, Charles Mason
Handy, Sherman Theodore
Haner, Jacob Leonard
Harrington, Daniel
Harris, Solomon Parker
Harris, Williams Cooper
Hefferan, George
Henley, Francis Neff
Henry, Frederick Augustus
Hepburn, Joseph Louis
Hepner, Herman Solomon
Hester, George Henry
Hickman, Henry Alonzo
Hindman, Willard Ward
Hirschi, Christian Gottlob
Hixson, Virgil Isaac
Holleran, Frank Lewis
Holmes, Arthur Kingsley
Hooker, Harry Eugene
Hosack, George Mechlin
Hubbard, Lorenzo Dow
Hubbard, Richard Langdon
Hughes, Thomas Welburn
Huntoon, John Clarence
Inghram, John Thomas
Inverarity, Duncan George
Irving, George
Irwin, Harry D.
Jewell, Harry Dimick
Johns, Henderson Franklin
Johnson, Fred Homer
Johnson, George Samuel
Johnson, Henry Lincoln
Jones, Oliver Morton
Kaufman, William
Kegley, William Bullard
Kelleher, John
Kelley, John Henry
Kelly, Frank Henry
Kendall, Arthur Jay
Kendall, George Abiathar
Knipp, Julius William
Knudson, Charles Oscar
Landauer, Herbert Thomas
Landiss, William
Lardner, Henry
Largent, John Amby
Lesh, Ulysses Samuel
Lewis, Thomas D.
Lindley, Irenaeus Cory
Lindley, William Orville
Lindsey, Washington Ellsworth
Long, Thomas Downs
Low, Samuel Elliott
Lynch, Francis James
Maple, Amos Colin
Masumoto, Yaichiro
Maughan, Willard Weston
McCabe, Arthur Johnson
McCabe, Edward David
McCoy, Herbert
McDonald, John Samuel
McGeagh, Joseph Samuel
McIntyre, George B.
McMaster, Frank Edgar
McNally, James Clifford
Middlecoff, Jehu Baker
Middlekauff, Charles Wilbur
Miles, Charles Vernon
Miller, Charles Frederic
Miller, Hugh John
Miller, John Marshall
Miller, William Manning
Mitchell, James Lewis
Mitchell, Oscar
Mitchell, U. S. Grant
Mohr, John Henry
Monroe, Stephen Blackmar
More, Ira
Moseley, Roland Fowler
Muir, Alexander McGlashan
Munger, Charles Webster
Muramatsu, Sanju
Murrell, William Blain
Myler, John Nicholas
Newcomer, John Rush
Ninde, Benjamin Frederic
Ninde, William Murray
Nye, George Lowe
O'Byrne, Daniel
Oldfather, Odell
O'Neill, Walter Bernard
Ottemeier, Henry Louis
Owen, Eber Ward
Park, James Alexander
Pavlicek, Charles Borromeo
Peirsol, Harry Allen
Peters, Melville Emerson
Petherbridge, Jesse Connell
Phillips, Norman Arter
Pierson, George Washington
Platt, Ralph
Porter, Ora Herbert
Pray, Dwight Alfred
Price, Enoch Jones
Puter, Lawrence Francis
Pyle, Emery Clinton
Quigley, Harry Nelson
Ramsay, William Butterfield
Rankin, Harry Dalton
Reader, Charles Marshall
Reeder, Levi Branson
Rhodes, Allin Lee
Roach, Michael
Robertson, Leslie Baker
Rood, John Romain
Rosenbluth, Miles
Ross, Frank Jackson
Rothschild, Leopold G.
Roudebush, John William
Rudkin, John Joseph
Sapinsky, Simon Morris
Schrider, John Henry
Shafer, Morgan Clement
Sherman, George Frederic
Shively, Dudley Morton
Siemon, Louis Jacob
Slack, William Herbert
Smith, John Davis
Snively, Sprague Ernest
Spotts, Edwin Robinson
St, Clair Harmon Chamberlin
Stansbury, John
Stark, Frederic Rollin
Stebick, Edward John
Steele, William Du Bose
Stillings, Presley Faris
Stillwell, Horace Conwell
Strong, John Elwin
Sutherland, Alexander Sinclair
Sutherland, Martin Ralph
Sutton, Eli Ransom
Sweet, Charles Elliott
Tabor, Ira Rolland
Taylor, Frank James
Taylor, Harold
Taylor, Hedley Clarence
Tewkesbury, David Bellinger
Thompson, William Edward
Todd, Theodore Walter
Townsend, Willis Leroy
Tyler, Emery Brainerd
Umlor, William Henry
Van, Vechten Edwin Francis
Vinsonhaler, Duncan MacArthur
Waller, Jesse Lester
Wanless, Will Frank
Waples, Belmont
Watanabe, Hango
Wefel, Herman Henry
Whitaker, William Jesse
Will, Arthur Percival
Williams, Stephen Douglas
Wilson, Hugh Edward
Wilson, Joseph R.
Wilson, Thomas Jefferson
Wissler, George Everhart
Wood, Charles Bishop
Wood, Henry Durland
Michigan Law Wordmark Print View